I’ve Been There: A Flashback On Why I Quit Dieting & Started Living Once and For All

[May ’09 – counting calories & deprivation]    [Summer ’12 – living my life – happy & carefree!]

note: I was not my heaviest here but still unhappy

One of the reasons I decided to pursue a career in holistic health counseling is because I’ve been there.

There as in a place where I tried everything (I mean everything!) to make my body change when it wouldn’t budge. There as in frantically adding up my calories for the day during Psychology class, while pretending to take notes. There as in canceling Mexican night with my girlfriends because I feared a margarita and quesadilla would make me fatter. There as in feeling like a little kid on Christmas every time the scale went down a pound, while feeling like I wanted to crawl in a hole and die every time it went up .2 pounds.

There as in hooking up with boys to make me feel better about myself and my body, and feeling I wasn’t skinny enough, pretty enough or good enough. There as in calling a pile of rice cakes with fat-free peanut butter “dinner.” There as in having a mental breakdown every time I ate something “bad”  and then rushing to the gym to “burn it off.” There as in looking in the mirror and hating what I saw.

Throughout my teenage years and part of my early-twenties, I tried hundreds of diets, shed countless tears, consumed pounds of “diet” food (I call it fake food now) and yo-yoed up and down in weight. Every day, I felt frustrated, tired and guilty. I wanted answers and I wanted them now but I was looking in all the wrong places: diets, restriction, outside approval.

I remember when I became fed up for the 1,000th time, I finally scheduled an appointment with a local nutritionist the summer after graduating from college. She had me bring in a list of everything I was eating, and so I did. It looked pretty much like this: egg beaters with veggies for breakfast, salads with fat-free dressing for lunch and diet meals or grilled chicken strips and microwavable veggies for dinner. I also consumed fruit, rice cakes, fat-free cheeses, sugar-free jello, Crystal Light, and anything labeled “Low Calorie!” or “Low fat!”

The nutritionist weighed me, told me that I was overweight for my weight range, looked at my food journal, and then I’ll never forget what she said to me next: “Nothing here stands out to me. It all comes down to one thing. You must be eating too many calories. Calories in, calories out.” Mind you, at the time I was exercising nearly every day!

I left there feeling completely shocked. Less calories, is she kidding me? I, even during my most distorted views on food, knew that couldn’t be right. I already knew I was restricting myself and that restricting myself even further wasn’t the answer. Looking back, I now can clearly see I was forcing my body in a state of starvation mode, wasn’t eating enough and most importantly wasn’t eating REAL FOOD. I was nutritionally deficient! No wonder I wasn’t happy with my body, nor losing weight.

But what that nutritionist said really stuck with me. The next day, I woke up and realized I had two choices. I could (a) continue the way I was eating and spend a lifetime depriving myself & cut my calories further as the nutritionist recommended or (b) Forget everything I ever told myself about eating and just live.

The thought of the first option made me sick to my stomach. If all of my friends can go out for pizza without having a panic attack and eat whatever the heck they wanted, then why should I need to cut back further? It simply didn’t seem fair. It wasn’t right, and I knew it. So I went with the latter, and decided that if I’m not losing weight by restricting myself to the limits, why not enjoy life instead even if that means gaining a couple of pounds?

I have to be honest: it was scary at first. Eating whatever I wanted, listening to my body (something I’ve never done) and trying to eat “normal” was so outside my comfort zone. But I did it. And every day it became easier. The best part? Once I started fueling my body with REAL food, loving myself for who I am, and experimenting with exercises that made me feel good inside, to my surprise the weight fell off.

I proved that nutritionist wrong.

A calorie is not a calorie if you’re nutritionally deficient and putting chemicals into your body.  Cutting back on calories isn’t going to make you lose weight if you are not happy on the inside. Living at the gym is not going to make frat boys want you more if you are not in love with yourself first. What you eat isn’t nearly as important as HOW YOU FEEL. Your relationship with yourself & your body is the most intimate and precious relationships of all. Women don’t need to spend their lives feeling guilty, alone and deprived. Life is meant to me enjoyed to the fullest!

This does not have to be you! If you see yourself in my story, please don’t hesitate to reach out to me. I am here for you because I would have died to have someone hold my hand, listen to me and tell me it was all going to be OK, to ask me “How do you feel?” So yes, I’ve been there…I’ve been SO there. And now I’m here to be there for YOU. Check out my health coaching programs for opportunities to work with me one-on-one.

Schedule my FREE Body Love Breakthrough Session today!

30 Responses to “I’ve Been There: A Flashback On Why I Quit Dieting & Started Living Once and For All”

  1. Caitlin Says:

    YES! A calorie of this is not equal to a calorie of that. I would much rather eat a rich cheese and savor each flavorful bite than that shredded low-fat stuff or a 50 calorie string cheese. I would rather eat a piece of really dark chocolate than a 100 calorie pack of Hostess cakes (oh man did I love those in college). I could eat rice cakes all day long…but I would never feel satisfied like I do after one of my huge salad beasts. I’m so proud of you for seeing an alternative OTHER than depriving yourself more, and instead nourishing yourself – body and soul. I honestly had no clue that you had ever been overweight because you are so fit and beautiful! I know that you will continue to inspire your readers and show them deprivation does not equal healthy.

  2. Sara @ Fit.Fun.Femme Says:

    Rachel! Your blog is amazing! So happy to now call myself a follower. Your story is beautiful and inspirational and I can’t wait to read more.

  3. Rachel @Healthy_Chicks Says:

    @Caitlin I couldn’t agree with you more on eating the rich, savory, nutrient-packed REAL version of a food over its its dead, low-cal bland counterpart.

    Thank you for your kind comments as always…they made me smile 🙂

  4. Rachel @Healthy_Chicks Says:

    @Sara Welcome to my blog, I am so glad that you stopped by and enjoyed the post! Hope to keep in touch with each other through the blog world xo xo

  5. Jess Says:

    Oh my gosh YES. REAL FOOD. NOURISHING FOOD. WHOLE FOOD. Yes, calories count — but not just the numerical value, but the nutrient value. Ahh I love this and it’s making me even MORE excited for our sushi date coming up soon!!!

  6. Rachel @ Healthy Chicks Says:

    @Jess Yes, yes and yes!! I just looked at my calendar and saw our sushi date written in and it made me so happy. The month is finally here!!

  7. jobo Says:

    LOVE this post!!! love it so much!! I think what is most powerful about your story is that you found your balance of eating that means fueling, delicious, healthy foods that are also SO TASTY and not at all depriving. It is refreshing, and real, and honest. It takes time, it takes mindfulness and really tuning in to your body, but it can be done. There is no quick fix, mentally, especially, but with time and patience, anything is possible!! love this! Can’t wait to meet up!!

  8. Rachel @Healthy Chicks Says:

    @jobo EXACTLY, ironically back then I was depriving myself and eating food that tastes like cardboard and NOW I am listening to my body & eating REAL, WHOLE foods that are so good I want to lick the plate! Many of these foods I feared back in the day because they were “too fatty” or “too many calories.” I’m so grateful I found that balance and want to share what I went through with as many women as possible.

  9. Danielle Says:

    What a great post! Yes, yes and yes to everything! I couldn’t agree with you more and have been through the same struggles myself! Great post!

  10. Rachel @Healthy Chicks Says:

    @Danielle Thank you!! The world is lucky to have people like us to share our stories & help others!

  11. Christine @ Love, Life, Surf Says:

    This is such a great post (that I finally have a chance to read)! Yes to everything that you’ve said – whole, nourishing, REAL food. Love hearing more about your story. It definitely takes a lot of effort and time to tune into our bodies but so important.

  12. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Friday Flashbacks: Fat Thighs & Embracing Your Imperfections Says:

    […] Week), the topic was disordered eating habits & ways we restrict ourselves as women. Since I have been there and now work with other women to overcome diet-obsessed living, they asked me to shine the light on […]

  13. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Friday Flashbacks: Bring Your Inner Sexy Out Says:

    […] to my looks, that is until I started dieting and well, my looks quickly became everything. I was consumed by my weight and how others, especially men, perceived me. Once I started getting attention from the guys, I […]

  14. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Friday Flashbacks: Treat Your Body With Love Says:

    […] I post a Friday Flashback, taking you on a journey back into my past life. Why? Well, because I’ve been there and can totally relate to body image issues, dieting struggles and all the other things in […]

  15. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » “Get Happy & Healthy” Wellness Challenge Day 1: On Being Mindful Says:

    […] that I hold very close to my heart, as it’s one of the major steps that helped me get over diet-obsessed living once and for […]

  16. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » I’ve Got an Announcement: My Big Hairy Audacious One-Year Goal Says:

    […] Because I’ve been there. […]

  17. Spring Cleaning for the Body & Mind (Without Dieting) ⁊ Share It Fitness Says:

    […] me, I’ve been there and that’s part of the reason I’m so anti-diet today. Throughout my late teens and […]

  18. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Why Your Relationship with Food is Directly Connected to Your Relationship with Money (& My Big Self Discovery) Says:

    […] over calories, the number on the scale and how much weight I had left to lose to the point where it consumed my life. I went through periods of bingeing (a.k.a. anxiously eating as much peanut butter out of the jar […]

  19. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Friday Flashback: Why Confidence Plays a Role in Your Weight Loss Journey Says:

    […] when I was dieting and in a pretty messed up relationship with the scale, my confidence level was about a 2 on a scale […]

  20. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Flashback Friday + 40 Reasons I’m Head Over Heels for Summer Says:

    […] I quit dieting and began to fall in love with life, the weight started to come off, the negative emotions started […]

  21. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » A Lesson from Geneen Roth: Eat The Foods That Hum To You Says:

    […] I didn’t know it at the time, I attribute losing weight & becoming more comfortable in my own skin (without dieting) to eating the foods that hum to me. No calorie counting. No judgement. No guilt. […]

  22. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Healthy Habits: Why Eating More Can Actually Help You Reach Your Weight Loss Goals Says:

    […] during my years of dieting (when I was eating diet, low calorie crap mind you) a nutritionist actually told me to eat less calories. “Calories in, calories out!” she cheerfully shouted, something I will never, ever […]

  23. great flash games Says:

    Heya i am for the primary time here. I found this board and I to find It really useful & it
    helped me out much. I hope to offer something again and help others like you helped me.

  24. game Says:

    It’s remarkable to go to see this site and reading the
    views of all friends regarding this post, while
    I am also keen of getting knowledge.

  25. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » Friday Flashbacks: Counting Calories Says:

    […] I reallllyyy struggled with the scale, dieting, counting calories and everything in between. I have been there, there as in a place I never want to be again, a place many of you may have been (or may be […]

  26. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » So, you wanna be a health coach? {My Personal Experience with the Institute for Integrative Nutrition & all your qs answered} Says:

    […] And then a kind o’ crazy thing started happening: I began losing weight, almost effortlessly. The weight I had held on from years of dieting, bashing my body, and weighing myself 5 times a day. The weight I kept as I told myself “You’re not pretty enough, skinny enough, or good enough.” The weight that haunted me when the nutritionist told me I needed to cut back even more on calories if I wanted to lose the weight for good. When I stopped depriving (and trying so damn hard), everything began to fall into its place. […]

  27. So, you wanna be a health coach? {My Personal Experience with the Institute for Integrative Nutrition | Beyond The Basics Health Academy Says:

    […] And then a kind o’ crazy thing started happening: I began losing weight, almost effortlessly. The weight I had held on from years of dieting, bashing my body, and weighing myself 5 times a day. The weight I kept as I told myself “You’re not pretty enough, skinny enough, or good enough.” The weight that haunted me when the nutritionist told me I needed to cut back even more on calories if I wanted to lose the weight for good. When I stopped depriving (and trying so damn hard), everything began to fall into its place. […]

  28. Healthy Chicks» Blog Archive » So you got your 6-pack…but are you happier? Says:

    […] felt angry. For myself (I’ve been there) For other women struggling with body image. For those who are vulnerable + often compare […]

  29. アフィリエイトってなぁに?山本謙吾と学ぶ Says:


    Here is my web blog :: アフィリエイトってなぁに?山本謙吾と学ぶ

  30. velo elliptique Says:

    Decant varier vos entrainements, choisissez un velo elliptique proposant des programmes preenregistres.

Leave a Reply

This entry was posted on Thursday, January 31st, 2013 at 10:28 pm and is filed under Body Image, Health & Wellness, Lifestyle. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Get on my list to receive FREE weekly bursts of healthspiration from yours truly (+ my 10 A-Hah Moments)!